ramimac's comments

ramimac | 1 year ago | on: A hard look at AWS GuardDuty shortcomings

> GuardDuty does what AWS says it will do

What do you view as AWS' commitments around GuardDuty? I see pretty clear positioning by AWS of GuardDuty as a one-and-done solution for threat detection.

Top level marketing claims include:

* "Protect against ransomware and other types of malware" - which is why I looked at how viable GuardDuty would be against the most common form of S3 "ransomware"

* "Detect suspicious activity in your generative AI workloads" - but they don't actually have coverage of the vast majority of GenAI Services

* "Continuous monitoring across AWS accounts and workloads without added cost" - except the service is expensive (if worthwhile for the foundational data sources!) and has unpredictable costs

> competing product/service

I see canary infrastructure as complimentary to Guardduty (w/ foundational data sources) - which is explicitly stated in the piece!

nb: I'm the author, in case it's non-obvious!

ramimac | 1 year ago | on: A hard look at AWS GuardDuty shortcomings

Agreed - I find the credential exfil alerts meaningful. I appreciate that AWS has invested in making them better in recent years (bypass details in https://hackingthe.cloud/aws/avoiding-detection/steal-keys-u...)!

I also find the DNS based cryptomining detections pretty handy, and high enough signal.

Great point on VPC Flow Logs! With the move to SKU off various GuardDuty features (S3 protection, Runtime, etc.) ... it'd be nice if GuardDuty monitoring of VPC Flow logs were more configurable

ramimac | 3 years ago | on: Ask HN: I'm now responsible of the security of a scaleup, how do I handle this?

There is a lot of advice in this thread that doesn't actually address your circumstances, or is just bad.

I recommend reading: 1. https://devd.me/log/posts/startup-security/ - relatively short and prescriptive 2. http://scrty.io/ - start with http://scrty.io/foundations + https://medium.com/starting-up-security/you-dont-need-a-chie... + https://medium.com/starting-up-security/starting-up-security...

page 1